Tuesday, September 20, 2011

Gold Rush: Expansion Details and Commentary

BANG! Gold Rush Expansion


Over a week ago, I noted the release of Gold Rush, the new official expansion to BANG!. I compared the expansion as incorporating elements of my Death Mesa, BANG! Tactics, and the accessory cards in Robbers' Roost beta. Today, I wanted to share some of the exciting details of the expansion.

BANG! Gold Rush Expansion Equipment Cards 2


The Equipment Cards. All of the new playing cards in Gold Rush are equipment cards. These equipment cards have a variety of border colors (the borders look like the event card borders at a glance); some being played once and then used (like brown-bordered cards), others played in front of you for future use (green/blue-bordered cards). For instance, "Pardner" is one of the brown colored equipment cards that he can be purchased. Upon playing it, a player can copy the effect of another brown-bordered card. Then it is discarded. Reminds you of Lee Van Kliff's ability, doesn't it? The "Horseshoe" card, on the other hand, is black-bordered, and so is played in front of you and used during "draws!". Equipment cards are not drawn from the normal playing deck. They instead constitute there own separate deck, much like in BANG! Tactics. 3 cards from this equipment deck are revealed at all times. During a player's playing phase (typically phase 2), the equipment cards that are revealed may be purchased. The moment one of them is purchased, a new equipment card is revealed.

Equipment cards must be purchased by spending golden nuggets. 30 of these nuggets are included in the game, but if you need more than 30, you are instructed to provide an equivalent (use pennies). They are earned 2 different ways. First, a golden nugget can be gained for each Beer card you play. Second, golden nuggets are earned by making other players take hits. Thus, if I hit a player with a BANG!, I immediately gain a golden nugget. If I hit 3 players with an Indians!, I immediately gain 3 golden nuggets. The accrued golden nuggets are placed in front of the players who earned them for all others to see.

BANG! Gold Rush Expansion Equipment Cards 1


Equipment cards cost a certain number of golden nuggets. This is displayed in the bottom right corner of the equipment card. To purchase an equipment card during a playing phase, a player only needs to expend the amount of golden nuggets described in the bottom right corner of the card. He then gains the card. If the equipment card is brown-bordered, it cannot be saved in one's hand. Rather, it is played immediately and then discarded. If it is black-bordered it is immediately put into play for its purchaser. As with other cards in play, a player cannot buy a duplicate black-bordered card. Any number of equipment cards may be purchased during his turn, and any number of types of black-bordered cards may be had in play.

Besides purchasing equipment cards during your playing phase, you may also discard equipment cards during your playing phase. This cannot be done through the typical use of a steal/discard card. Rather, you can only do so by expending 1 more than the number of golden nuggets that an equipment card costs. The owner of the equipment card cannot prevent its discard. Obviously, only black-bordered equipment cards can be discarded since the brown-bordered ones are played immediately during the purchaser's turn. It isn't clear at the moment whether or not one can discard their own equipment cards this way. For instance, I might want to discard a black-bordered card in front of me, and then purchase a duplicate of that card revealed in the equipment pile to prevent someone else from getting it.

When an equipment card is used or discarded, place it face up at the bottom of the equipment deck. When a face up card is revealed this signals that the equipment deck needs to be reshuffled. Interestingly, upon player elimination the equipment cards are discarded, but Vulture Sam does not get to pick them up (bummer for him; I can easily see a house rule made to change this).

BANG! Gold Rush Characters


Character Cards. Gold Rush adds 8 new characters to BANG!: Don Bell, Dutch Will, Jacky Murieta, Josh McCloud, Madam Yto, Pretty Luzena, Raddie Snake, and Simeon Picos. Some of these abilities are pretty neat, such as the ability to "draw!" for an additional turn, to pay golden nuggets to fire a BANG!, to gain golden nuggets when any player plays a Beer, and to have all the costs of equipment cards lowered by 1. Most of the abilities look like they depend on using equipment cards or golden nuggets, so they do have the disadvantage of being less modular. In other words, they wouldn't work well with incorporating them with just the base game. The Dodge City and Wild West Show characters, on the other hand, worked quite will with this incorporation. However, these 8 characters in Gold Rush were designed with the Shadow Gunslinger variant in mind.

BANG! Gold Rush Shadow Gunslingers


Shadow Gunslinger Variant. In this variant, eliminated players can still affect the game. When a player is eliminated, he discards all of his cards like usual, but keeps his golden nuggets. On all of his future turns, he temporarily re-enters play as a shadow version of his previous role (shadow-renegade, shadow-outlaw, shadow-deputy). He draws 2 cards, uses them if he can, and then disappears from the game again at the end of his turn. Since he cannot gain/lose life points, he is not really eliminated at the end of his turn, and so player elimination abilities (Herb Hunter, Vulture Sam, Greg Digger) do not get any benefits from this. As someone has already pointed out, this variant is basically like a permanent Ghost Town. The only difference is that the shadow players can gain gold nuggets from turn to turn. This allows them to save up to purchase equipment cards, which I imagine only the brown-bordered ones would be of any use to buy. However, you could discard others' black-bordered equipment cards. One other specification is made for shadow gameplay: Dynamite skips the shadow players for "draws!".

There are also special rules for Shadow Renegade. Death Mesa tried to keep the Renegade aspect of the Renegade through the Zombie Renegade. Gold Rush throws in the towel in trying to balance him and just appropriates him into the Sheriff or Outlaw team. While his allegiance to these teams changes, it is never his choice. On his turn, he sides with the weakest team (the team with the least amount of living players). The calculation for his allegiance is simple: Whatever team has the most face up roles cards, he joins. The "face up roles card" specification is so that it includes all shadow players, plus the Sheriff, whose role card is always revealed. If there is a tie between the two teams, he sides with the Outlaws. The Renegade has a 2-sided shadow role card to indicate which team he is currently aligned with.

Initial Thoughts. There is a lot about the Gold Rush expansion that looks good. I think accruing the golden nuggets will be a lot of fun, and the shop mechanic with it looks pretty smooth and great. I hope this will create a lot of what I envisioned in BANG! Tactics. How useful the equipment cards will be depends a lot upon their specific effects, which have not been fully disclosed at the moment. I hope they will allow for a lot more strategic gameplay. It will be interesting to see how they balance out between the more defensive versus offensive characters. Big Spencer looks like a living gold mine for accruing golden nuggets. I really enjoy the idea of accruing golden nuggets by playing Beer too.

As for concerns, I am a little disappointed that the characters are so gold nugget focused, but it may really help with the Shadow Gunslinger variant, so I will try to give it some slack. I prefer expansions that are more modular. The Shadow Gunslinger variant I am not completely sold on. It seems to give the Outlaws a better advantage as shadow gunmen, but perhaps the Renegade's switching allegiance will help? From face value, it doesn't look sufficient. Also, it seems to favor certain characters as shadow players. What good are defensive characters, life point sacrificing/regaining characters (Chuck Wengam, Bill Noface, Sid Ketchum), and card limit characters (Sean Mallory, Big Sepncer) as shadow players? Offensive characters (Slab the Killer) and card drawing/transmuting characters (Jose Delgado, Pixie Pete, Black Jack) have a huge advantage over them. While this is why the Gold Rush characters have been more specifically designed with the variant in mind, who wants to play with only the 8 Gold Rush characters? It would seem to make more sense to simply eliminate all character abilities for shadow players.

But this the designers do not want to do, because while the Shadow Gunslinger saves BANG! from many of the problems of player elimination, it sacrifices a lot of hand building continuity and planning. Some of this is made up by the accrual and usage of the golden nuggets, and the Gold Rush characters' abilities especially interact with the golden nuggets to help with that. Unfortunately, this brings us back to the favoring of certain characters problem. I think some house rules will have to be invented to sort this out. And even with these fixes, I don't know if the golden nuggets will deliver enough continuity and strategy for the shadow players.

The next problem, which really bugs me, is how much the gunslingers break up character ability gameplay since they draw from the normal deck. Kit Carlson can no longer stack up dynamite "draws!" to explode, since the shadow player in between the living player will pick it up. Similarly, an ally of Pedro Ramirez cannot stack a card on the discard pile for him to pick up if a shadow player is in the way. His jail gauntlet ability will also be completely destroyed. I tried to avoid many of these problems in Death Mesa by incorporating the Dead Men's Deck instead.

Fortunately, I think Death Mesa and Gold Rush are easily compatible. Gold nuggets will remain with ghosts upon death, and they will be able to accrue/use them just like the shadow players. Equipment cards can be purchased and discarded, but as with the shadow players, they will not be able to keep black-bordered cards at the ends of their turns. This, I hope, may provide a more satisfying solution to the player elimination problem while also incorporating the benefits of Gold Rush.

As for the Shadow Renegade solution, I do not know what to think of it. It sure makes the Renegade's life easier, and maybe that is best, instead of trying to find a way to revamp him as I do with the Zombie Renegade. On the other hand, I think the Renegade is a fun player in the game, and it is sort of sad to throw in the towel on his "last man standing" victory conditions. The verdict is out on this one.

Anyway, on the whole I am quite excited about Gold Rush, and expect it to be at least as good an addition to BANG! as Dodge City. You can check out the Gold Rush rulebook that was put online here. If you are interested in Gold Rush, check out my post on the Board Game Geek interview with Roberto Corbelli about Gold Rush. I have posted all of the characters and their abilities there.

20 comments:

  1. It looks like this expansion tries fill the problematic holes in the classic Bang game. More tactical aspect and no more waiting if the game ends. This sounds cool, but when I read your description, I was pretty disapointed. Especially the shadow gunslinger mode sounds like the Sheriff will have even more trouble than before to stay alive.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Sorry that I disappointed you so much on the initial review! In general, I like the equipment cards. I am just skeptical about the shadow gunslinger mode. But maybe it really works well--they have playtested it a lot. If all else fails, it is still compatible with Death Mesa.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I totally agree with you. Card-drawing abilities will be even stronger now and the weaker characters cannot catch up, because of the not-discardable equipment-cards. Even without using WildWestShow people complain about having Luckyduke. Now they will complain about not having PixiePete.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Sorry Martin, I didn't mean your description, I'm just little sceptical about how the Shadow Gunslinger will work. Especially the Renegade part is strange: his role typically is to fool anyone else in the game, and I just cannot see him playing in Sheriff's team. And one of the coolest thing in the classic bang! is that you can win alone with the Renegade, so I would hoped something similiar than in Death Mesa.

    The equipment idea seems much more cooler than the shadow mode, but it will be more complex to teach new players to play the game. I guess this expansion is not for beginners.

    Even I'm not sure how things will work with this version, I will definetly buy it! =)

    ReplyDelete
  5. Some clarifications:
    - "this variant is basically like a permanent Ghost Town"
    not exactly, Shadows cannot gain life points, ex. Chuck Wengam in Ghost Town could do it and then use ability, as Shadow he cannot
    - "it seems to favor certain characters as shadow players. What good are (...) Chuck Wengam, Bill Noface, Sid Ketchum)"
    the concept is right, balance as Shadow is different as balance alive, but wrong about Bill Noface. He gets "only" 5 cards per turn! ;-)

    I can confirm that balance of the game may go a little bit more towards the outlaws but only if they are at distance 1 from the Sheriff.

    As last, shadow rule has a big advantage... to be a rule! This means you could not use if you prefer, or even use without playing GR! It's up to you. Personally, I'm confident it will be appreciated by the most once played it.

    Have fun with GR! :-)

    ReplyDelete
  6. Thanks for the clarifications, Paolo. I will edit my original post to add in some of your points. Wow, Bill Noface will be a hooker. But I am again concerned that around 1/2 of the characters will be worthless shadow players. Most likely, I see players adopting a no character ability house rule for balance.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Could you perhaps post a more complete list of the new characters abilities?

    ReplyDelete
  8. There actually isn't a complete list of the new character abilities yet; this was inferred from the rulebook that DV-Giochi released in their September 2011 newsletter. The only character whose ability is completely spelled out Pretty Luzena: "Once on her turn, she may buy 1 equipment at a cost reduced by 1 gold nugget." Once I find out more I will post it here.

    ReplyDelete
  9. About the Shadow Gunslinger variant I use this house rules:

    - No Shadows characters ability.
    - Deputy Can Become Sheriff (to balance shadow outlows).
    - No Shadows Gunslinger during final duel (Scheriff vs Renegade).

    ReplyDelete
  10. Does anyone know a webstore where I can purchase the Gold Rush expansion? I tried to purchase on DvGiochi webstore, but they charged me 40€ to shipping services (Brazil). It's more than double the price of the expansion (16.9€).

    ReplyDelete
  11. you can buy it on amazon

    ReplyDelete
  12. I have a question, since I don't yet see a Gold Rush FAQ on your site--(thanks for the others, though!).

    Since the rules say you can pay to remove equipment from another player, there's no way to get rid of your own Wanted poster, right?

    ReplyDelete
  13. Where can i download the softcopy of the card? really want to play it..
    thanks. i like this blog very much...

    ReplyDelete
  14. Its very well detailed and appealing to keep to eye to read more.
    We also try to keep our blog filled with information and helpful methods to help anyone with carpet problems.
    Once again great blog. Very well informative.want to see more detail visit
    http://thegoldrushstore.com/about-us/
    sell gold jewelry

    ReplyDelete
  15. Chúng tôi nhận ship hàng từ úc về việt nam. Với kinh nghiệm nhiều năm và các dịch vụ đang cung cấp như nhận order hàng mỹ, mua hàng mỹ online, mua hàng usa,
    gửi hàng từ đức về việt nam, gửi hàng từ anh về việt nam. Hãy đến với chúng tôi nếu bạn đang có nhu cầu sử dụng dịch vụ nhận Order hàng UK.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Người Nhật có tuổi thọ cao, vóc dáng quyến rũ, không béo chủ yếu là do do họ có “bí quyết riêng”. Bí quyết 9 lý do khiến phụ nữ Nhật Bản trẻ lâu.

    ReplyDelete
  17. Good article, I really like this article, if you are interested can look at my site www.zyy.com

    ReplyDelete
  18. Kami adalah industri Toko Mebel furniture minimalis menjual mebel berkualitas harga murah Mebel Jepara Minimalis yang tentunya dengan kualitas terbaik dan khas dari pengrajin mebel dengan ukiran mebel minimalis Jati katalog produk mebel kami banyak dan lebih dari ratusan hingga ribuan produk yang bisa anda cek disini meja makan minimalis dengan harga yang relatif murah anda sudah bisa mendapatkan produk Kamar Set Jati Minimalis asli produk mebel minimalis jepara yang berkualitas dan di kerjakan oleh para tukang kayu asli jepara yang sudah berpengalaman di bidangny. Selain itu toko mebel kami juga menjual produk kursi tamu minimalis asli produk jati dari jepara, Di samping itu produk yang kami tawarkan memang benar-benar mempunyai kualitas tinggi, tersedia juga produk buffet minimalis yang merupakan salah satu produk utama yang harus ada dalam satu hunian rumah kami sediakan dengan berbagai macam model Meja Makan Minimalis produk minimalis yang tentunya sangat elegant Kursi untuk ruang Tamu Jati Minimalis sampai dengan model yang mewah yang tentunya. kemewahan dari produk yang kami tawarkan berbeda dengan yang lain contohnya set kursi sofa produk modern berbahan baku jati yang tentunya sangat awet untuk anda peroleh untuk ditempatkan di rumah anda, semua itu anda bisa melihatnya di katalog produk tempat tidur minimalis asli karya toko jati Mebel Jepara Minimalis. Kami juga ada produk modern berbahan baku jati yang tentunya sangat awet untuk anda peroleh untuk ditempatkan di rumah anda, semua itu anda bisa melihatnya di katalog produk mebel jati dan untuk semua produk yang kami koleksi nantinya produk tersebut akan kami tawarkan sesuai dengan harga mebel tempat tidur. Anda jangan khawatir karena produk yang kami jual itu mempunyai kualitas yang terjamin yang di buat oleh para pengrajin kursi sofa minimalis yang sudah berpengalaman di bidangnya. Tentunya kami tidak ingin mengecewakan para konsumen kami,maka dari itu kami memberikan produk toko mebel online dengan harga yang terjangkau. Semua furniture yang kami jual adalah produk dari kami dan jika anda ingin melihat koleksi furniture dari jepara anda bisa mengunjungi toko furniture online jepara yang berkualitas dan terpercaya. Jangan pernah tertipu berbelanja furniture secara online yang mengatas namakan mebel jepara,hanya di sini anda bisa mendapatkan furniture jati yang berkualitas asli jepara.

    ReplyDelete